Share what you know with millions of people

Focus is the best place to turn what you know into remarkable content
×
0

Will you ever completely abandon your desktop for mobile devices? Is mobile the new desktop?

Attachments

1
Bob Egan
Managing Director
Posted on Aug. 3, 2011

If we think about mobile as a style of use, versus a consideration that describes what a device looks like, then i think mobile train has already left the station.

In terms of the user experience created "at" the desktop, then its tough to see how that would go away, but it is controlled and utility derived by devices which can easily carried, like smart-phones or tablets.

The bottom line:
The desktop is already like Cinderella's stepsisters: loud, ugly and unwanted. Mobile is like Lady Gaga, inventive, surprising and talented...

0
Shawn Yeager
Shawn Yeager Replied on Aug. 18, 2011

I like Bob's way of re-framing the question. Technically, speaking, I haven't used a "desktop" in over 8 years, but if I look at PC (as defined by desktop or laptop) versus mobile (in my case, iPhone and iPad), then I still see combined usage for some time to come.

At the risk of turning this into an Apple commercial, my recent purchase of a MacBook Air has changed my usage patterns considerably. Where I previously was toting around an iPad as my ultra-mobile, the Air has taken its place. It's fast enough with a big enough display combined with feather weight and great battery life, but the kicker is the keyboard.

And to me, that's the bottom line: I'm just not as fast and productive on any device as I am one with a full keyboard. Until the much storied but little realized voice control interfaces mature, I don't see any sea changes in usage.

0
Robert Keahey
IT, Business and Social Strategist/Commentator, SummaLogic LLC
Posted on Aug. 3, 2011
  • Recommended by:

Great analogy Bob! Today's Dilbert cartoon was pretty cool too - the Gen-Xer (or is it Y or Z or have we started over with A now...) calling Dilbert's desktop machine a "grandpa box".

Some people won't have to abandon the desktop because they'll never have one. Others will rely primarily on a mobile platform and use the desktop (laptop) for a few specific functions. Then there will be a group that reverses that model - people who are deep into certain roles that mobile can't yet support, and probably won't ever be practical for anyway, such as heavy graphics design, modeling/analytics that require those ginormous spreadsheets, etc. It's going to be a fun ride for IT people over the next few years as we sort out how to manage the variety of devices.

Like the mainframe, the desktop will never totally disappear, but it's probably wise to stock up on spare parts just in case...

I think that's Lady Gaga I hear singing in the background.

0
James Ketner
James Ketner Replied on Aug. 3, 2011

Fundamentals of power to processor will determine. Just as drives have gotten smaller, I so believe that processors to battery size will as well. This will allow the heavy users. Now if someone creates a dongle to HDTV the monitor would be covered. Oh that's right Apple has as well as certain android vendors (Atrix). I think Lady Gaga will be doing encores!

0
Andrew Baker
Andrew Baker Replied on Aug. 3, 2011

Today's Dilbert was ridiculously funny. :)

0
Andrew Baker
Director, Service Operations, SWN Communications Inc.
Posted on Aug. 3, 2011
  • Recommended by:

I imagine that I'll eventually ditch desktops and laptops for mobile devices. Maybe.

But not within the next 18-24 months, likely. I do an increasing amount of computing on my phone, but it is not the best place for me to do all the things I like or need to do with technology, particularly when it comes to content creation and systems administration. (The awesomeness of being surrounded by 2 or more 22" wide screens is way too much to give up anytime soon!)

The mobile devices need to get a bit more power and provide ease of major input.

Mobile might be the new desktop for some, but not for me. Even today, I'm not at the place where my laptop is my primary computing device, and they're much more powerful than their more portable mobile cousins.

The biggest boon to mobile computing will be real battery life improvements -- you know, days to weeks between charges.

0
Sunil  Kumar G
IT/IS Manager, Wipro Ltd
Posted on Aug. 3, 2011
  • Recommended by:

i agree to your point Mr. Baker, since i have been using BB for more than 6 yrs and i cannot think of throwing away my laptop for BB or for any mobile device. All i feel in case of mobile device we will tend to loose our English because we "stop words" rather than long and well communicated mail. till date i only use BB for sending short mails not for sending any communication mails.

considering the battery life is low in most of the mobile device and kind of application we tend to use.

0
Bruce Burke
President & Founder, Gulf Bay Consulting, LLC
Posted on Aug. 4, 2011
  • Recommended by:

I've got the last desktop I think I'll ever own up for sale on Craigslist right now! It's not moving even though I keep dropping the price and reposting the item moving it to the front of the line... I've become a big proponent of mobile first and have even developed my own concept about the the death of the desktop and all other static Information and Communication Technologies (ICT). I refer to this decade as Generation-M!

I've started writing a blog entitled "It's Generation-M!" on new entrant Mobile Payments Today. In the first post "Welcome to Generation M" I defined my concept for the readers so they could understand my viewpoint and assertions. I've provided the link to the first post here: http://www.mobilepaymentstoday.com/blog/5738/Welcome-to-Generation-M

I'm currently organizing an event that focuses on the convergence of social media, mobile connectivity and payment technology. I'm dubbing the event Social : Mobile : Payments | Conference & Exhibition. I'm currently organizing venue, speakers, sponsors, and media partners. I've got a website in development over at http://www.socialmobilepayments.com If anyone cares to get involved please feel free to drop me a line. - Thank you

0
  • Recommended by:

Possibly, and it's a matter of finding a suitable replacement of both hardware and Cloud services to make the transition complete.

0
Maurene Grey
Founder, Principal Analyst, Grey Consulting
Posted on Aug. 4, 2011
  • Recommended by:

As Bob says, "the mobile train has left the station." However, here I am typing from the station. My laptop has Wi-Fi, but I'm tethered to my desk because all my work material is here. I own a 3G smartphone through which I read and respond to email--as nimbly as my fingers will allow.

CNN on my tablet feeds my morning news fix. My smartphone's QR reader satisfies my need for instant gratification when trying to decipher a mysterious-looking square.

I own a desktop, laptop, netbook, tablet and smartphone. (Have yet to invest in an eReader.)

Bottom line: One-size doesn't fit all. (and, yes, I still have my landline.)

0
  • Recommended by:

I view it more as a continuum than an either or. My son in high school lived with mobile devices (Ipod touch and phone). PC was for papers or research but not as a regular need. As he's moved to college laptop is more part of his need for research/papers, communication that mobile devices can't support. I see tablet in his future real soon, too, as he moves along the continuum to more mobile. If a mobile device had an expandable screen we'd see consolidation. I'd expect him to drop the laptop and go table with minimal keyboard for those typing needs.

Answer This Question